People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Giant slices. NY style. I only had peperoni, but this is not gourmet pizza. This is comfort food at its best. Nothing about it screamed at me, but it was perfect and what it was...a slice of NY style pizza. Greasy in all the right places. Nice thin crust. The sauce and cheese were banging. Cheesy and stringy goodness! I HIGHLY recommend this place. It was amazing. ”
“ Quality, fresh, well put together! The right fresh bread. Fresh deli meats, crisp lettuce! Spectacular Italian Grinder. The pizza Slices ARE HUGE and delicious! Simplicity quality, Nice to have places like this still around. ”
“ The food was really good. This was the first time I was here, but I will definitely return we ate in, and the owner was very friendly he even offered to make a small pizza while I waited for my girlfriend to get there. If you haven't tried this location, you are missing out. ”
“ Went in for a slice since I was starving and had a long ride ahead of me. The place is tiny but the food was great. Everyone that came in was served quickly. It had a nice hometown feel “where everybody knows your name”. I got a cheese slice with sausage and pepperoni added. This was the BIGGEST slice I’ve ever had in my life. Too big to eat while driving, but still delicious and inexpensive for what it was. I’d def go back and order a whole pie next time. ”
“ The pizza here is incredible! Highly recommend you get a slice or a pie. The single slices are huge! More like 2-3 slices in 1! ”
“ We’ve been patronizing Carminuccio’s since we moved to CT 15 years ago. Our favorite is the red pepper and sausage pizza and it has been consistently good! Just went tonight and enjoyed the pie and salad. Go check them out! ”
“ The service and food were amazing!! Their mushroom & eggplant pizza is sooooo delicious!! We will keep going back!! ”
“ Food was exceptional. Didn't know what to think when I got there but I was super impressed. Reminds me of an off the beaten path dive. But, let me say the food is worth the trip! A and yes the slices are massive! ”
Menu
Fried Mozzarella Sticks (6)
US$6.50No cheese pizza:
Carmine Special
Sicilian Pizza(16 Slices)
Insalata Pizza
About
Carminuccio's Pizza & Subs
Welcome to the delightful world of Carminuccio's Pizza & Subs, a cozy gem nestled at 76 S Main St, Newtown, CT. This charming establishment is not just a pizzeria; it's a community hub where the love for classic New York-style comfort food thrives. With a phone call to +1 203-364-1133, you can place your order and join the local enthusiasts celebrating their passion for hearty meals.
When stepping into Carminuccio's, the aroma of freshly baked pizza greets you, promising a taste that’s both authentic and satisfying. As customer reviews pour in, one thing is clear: this spot is legendary for its giant slices. Whether you opt for the classic pepperoni or venture into the realm of their spectacular Italian grinders, the quality is consistently praised. Keith S waxes poetic about the combination of flavors, noting that while it may not be gourmet, it captures the essence of comfort food perfectly—a sentiment echoed by many patrons seeking a taste of home.
The standout feature? Those massive slices. According to Ken Morning, these pieces of pizza are substantial enough to be described as "two or three slices in one." You won’t need to break the bank for an indulgent meal here; the prices are as appealing as the food itself. The thin crust is crispy and greasy in all the right places, harmoniously complemented by a savory sauce and the "cheesy and stringy goodness" that Keith S raves about.
Moreover, it's not just about the pizza. The subs receive high acclaim as well, with James Cormier highlighting the fresh bread and quality deli meats that make the Italian Grinder a must-try. Each bite is a testament to the care that goes into crafting each dish, ensuring that you leave with a satisfied palate and a smile on your face.
In a world where fast food has overshadowed the authenticity of traditional eateries, Carminuccio's serves as a beautiful reminder of what good food truly means. The friendly owner, who takes the time to make guests feel welcome, shines through the reviews as a symbol of the genuine warmth that emanates from this place. Mark Carriero notes this hospitality, making it not just a meal, but a memorable experience.
If you haven't experienced the joy of Carminuccio's Pizza & Subs yet, you're missing out. Join the locals who cherish their slices and subs, and discover why this establishment is held in such high regard. Whether for a quick slice on the go or a leisurely meal shared with friends, Carminuccio's is a celebration of great food and community spirit. Dive in, and let the flavors transport you to the bustling streets of New York—one gigantic slice at a time!
Book a table